signup for the hometown favorites newsletter  JOIN OUR NEWSLETTER
888-694-2656
Shop By

Shopping Options

Brands
  1. Annabelle Candy (3)
  2. Atkinson's Candy (6)
  3. Boyer (5)
  4. Brown & Haley (1)
  5. Hershey's (3)
  6. Necco Candy (5)
  7. Nestle (1)
By Decade
  1. 1950's Candy (5)
  2. 1960's Candy (2)
  3. 1970's Candy (2)
color
  1. Red (6)
  2. Orange (9)
  3. Green (2)
  4. Purple (5)
  5. Black (1)
  6. Brown (4)

Peanut Butter Candy

Image size: SM MD LG
27 items
Page:
Image size: SM MD LG
27 items
Page:
WHERE YOU'VE SEEN US
hometown favorites on the food network
hometown favorites on oprah
hometown favorites in the new york times
ABOUT HOMETOWN FAVORITES
Hometown Favorites is your online destination for old fashioned and nostalgic candies, online grocery shopping and unique gifts. We carry a large assortment of retro candy from the 1950's, 1960's, 1970's, 1980's, and 1990's. Rediscover old grocery store favorites and hard-to-find foods like Cheerwine, Nehi Soda, Duncan Hines, Ralston Hot Cereal, Count Chocula cereal and thousands more.
QUICK LINKS
ABOUT US
NEED HELP?
LET'S TALK
© Copyright 2012 Hometown Favorites, LLC. All Rights reserved. Privacy Policy
Order Securely Online or Call 1-888-694-2656